Introduction

Tertiary health institutions offer services to patients that are self-referred or those referred by primary, secondary and other tertiary health facilities depending on the available facilities and skilled manpower. Hospital admission patterns give an insight into the disease burden in a particular region and assists in health care planning and performance evaluations of a hospital. Medical admissions are important as a reflection of common diseases in the society 2, 1 . It is worthy of note that medical diseases constitute the most common cause of death in adults 3 . The pattern of medical admissions varies from one health facility to another depending on the prevailing medical diseases in the region, education, hygiene, lifestyle and health-seeking behaviors of the population vis-a-vis available health services.

However, hospital based studies cannot replace population based studies which are the gold standard for determining the incidence, prevalence, morbidity and mortality of diseases in a community. Population based studies are not available in most parts of the world because of lack of the expertise, reliable data bases, disease registries and resource constraints4 . Hospital based studies give an insight into disease burden in a community and help clinicians, public health professionals and policy makers to make informed decisions regarding individual patient and population care in addition to planning health care delivery system5 . In the past, communicable diseases accounted for most of the medical admissions across sub Saharan Africa6 . But, there is a current global trend towards NCDs as documented in some literatures8, 7 . Adult mortality in sub Saharan Africa is 4 – 40 times more than in developed countries 11, 10, 9 and the pattern of diseases responsible for this high adult mortality is not well characterized 14, 13, 12 .

There seems to be wide variations in the patterns and outcomes of medical admissions observed in hospital-based studies across many cities in Nigeria 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15 , Uganda 23 . India 24 and Saudi Arabia25 . It has been projected by the WHO that by 2020, NCDs would surpass infectious diseases as the main cause of medical admissions and adult deaths 26 . However, Etyang and Gerard Scott in their systematic review concluded that cardiovascular and infectious diseases were currently the leading causes of admissions and in-patient deaths in sub Saharan Africa27 .

There is a dearth of published literatures on the diseases burden and treatment outcome in the only tertiary health facility in the commercial city of Aba in Abia state, Nigeria where lots of mercantile activities take place. We, therefore, set out to study the disease patterns and outcome of treatment in the medical wards of ABSUTH, Aba.

METHODOLOGY

A retrospective descriptive analysis was carried out on medical records of patients admitted into the male and female medical wards of ABSUTH, Aba. Aba is a commercial city in the Southeastern region of Nigeria known for her industrial, mercantile and craftwork activities. The hospital is the only tertiary health facility in Aba and gets referrals from all the primary and secondary health facilities in Aba and the neighboring states. The study covered a period of ten years between May 1, 2007 and April 30, 2017. Using the Nurse's Inpatient Admissions/Discharge Registers in the male and female medical wards, nurses report books and in some cases, case notes of some patients from the Medical Records Department of the hospital, all the patients admitted in the medical wards were recruited. Patients whose data were incomplete were excluded and all the diagnoses were based on the final diagnoses made by the supervising consultants. These diagnoses were arrived at on combination of clinical and laboratory parameters of the patients. Co morbid conditions were not included as diagnosis. Duration of hospital stay of 1 day refers to patients in whom the outcome of admission occurred within 24 hours of admission in the medical wards.

The following data were collected from each patient's record – age, gender, definitive diagnosis, duration of hospital stay and outcome during admission. In this study, the outcome measures were discharged home, died, discharged against medical advice (DAMA) or transferred to another specialty outside the medical wards or to another health facility. The diseases diagnosed were grouped into body systems according to the WHO International Statistical Classification of Diseases version 10 (ICD-10) guidelines 28 .

Ethical approval was obtained from the Institution's Ethics and Research Committee before commencing the study. Data obtained were analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS Inc. Chicago IL) version 20.0 software. Qualitative data were expressed as frequencies and percentages while quantitative data were summarized as means and standard deviations. P values of <0.05 was regarded as statistically significant.

RESULTS

A total of 6587 admissions were recorded in the medical wards within the study period. There were 3153 males (47.9%) and 3434 females (52.1%) with a ratio of 1: 1.08. The age range was 15 – 103 years with a mean age of 52.34 ± 18.17; male 53.10 ± 18.29, female 51.64 ± 18.04. The differences in the mean ages of the male and female patients admitted in the medical wards of ABSUTH was statistically significant (p<0.05). The minimum age of both male and female participants in the study was 15 years but the maximum ages of the males and females were 99 and 103 years respectively. The middle aged (33.4%) and the elderly patients (39.6%) formed a majority of the medical admissions while the teenagers (2.9%) were the least admitted in the medical wards (table 5). The mean duration of hospital stay was 9.97±9.77 days with a range of hospital stay of 1 – 123 days; male 9.86±9.33, female 10.07±10.15. The demographic characteristics of the participants were as shown in Table 2, Table 1 .

Table 1 Demographic characteristics of medical admissions in ABSUTH
Indices Frequency (n=6587) (%)
Age categories (years)<2020-3940-5960 and aboveTotal 193 (2.9)1584 (24.0)2197 (33.4)2613 (39.7)6587 (100)
Gender:MaleFemale 3153 (47.9)3434 (52.1)

Table 2 Age distribution of the subjects
Mean age (±SD)Mean age male (±SD)Mean age female (±SD) 52.34±18.1753.10±18.3051.64±18.04 (t=3.268, p=0.001)

Pattern of diseases causing medical admissions in ABSUTH, Aba.

The commonest diseases responsible for admissions in the medical wards within the study period were diabetes mellitus related complications (18.5%) followed by HIV/AIDS (12.9%), stroke (12.6%), heart failures (12.1%), chronic kidney diseases (CKD) (5.6%), systemic arterial hypertension (4.8%), chronic liver diseases (4.7%) and acute malaria (4.1%). Communicable diseases (infectious and parasitic diseases) constituted 26.7% of the medical admissions while non-communicable diseases accounted for 73.3%. When presented according to systems of the body, infectious and parasitic diseases came up top, followed by the cardiovascular system, endocrine diseases (diabetes mellitus mainly), and the nervous system. Details are shown in Table 4, Table 3 .

Table 3 Spectrum of the major diseases causing hospitalization in the medical wards of ABSUTH, Aba, within the study period isshown below:
Diseases Male Female Total (n=6587) (%))
HIV/AIDS 365 487 852 (12.9)
Malaria 138 135 273 (4.1)
Sepsis 88 72 160 (2.4)
PTB / extrapulmonary TB 89 61 150 (2.3)
Stroke 382 449 831 (12.6)
Diabetes mellitus related complications 599 621 1220 (18.5)
Heart failure 373 421 794 (12.1)
Hypertension 103 213 316 (4.8)
Chronic liver diseases 175 135 310 (4.7)
Acute viral hepatitis 39 27 66 (1.0)
PUD 24 43 67 (1.0)
CAP/suppurative lung disease 57 76 133 (2.0)
COPD/chronic bronchitis/emphysema 33 36 69 (1.0)
CKD/nephrolithiasis 209 163 372 (5.6)
Lymphoma/breast CA/other malignancies 33 30 63(1.0)
Miscellaneous diseases 446 465 911(13.8)
Communicable diseases (Infectious and parasitic diseases) 1757 (26.7)
NCD 4830 (73.3%)

Table 4 Spectrum of diseases causing medical admissions in ABSUTH based on the ICD-10
Code Diseases Frequency (n=6587) (%)
A or B Infectious and parasitic diseases 1757 (26.7%)
C Malignant neoplasms 130 (2.0%)
D Anemia 72 (1.1%)
E Endocrine, nutritional and metabolism 1229 (18.7%)
F Mental and behavioural disease 33 (0.5%)
2 Diseases of the nervous system 971 (14.7%)
I Diseases of the circulatory system 1265 (19.2%)
J Diseases of the respiratory system 268 (4.1%)
K Diseases of the digestive system 464 (7.1%
M Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissues 23 (0.4%)
Diseases of the genitourinary system 255 (3.9%)
R Others 120 (1.8%)

Outcome of hospitalization in the medical wards

A total of 4569 admissions (69.4%) into the medical wards improved and were discharged home, 1491 (22.6%) died, 289 (4.4%) were discharged home against medical advice and 238 (3.6%) were transferred to other centres or specialtiesTable 5 . With a medical ward mortality of 22.6%, the major causes of death within the study period were stroke (5.34%), HIV/AIDS (4.24%), DM related complications (3.78%), heart failures (1.61%) and CKD (1.69%) as shown in Table 6 . The differences in the outcome of the male and female patients were not statistically significant (X2 = 5.811, p > 0.05). The outcome for the different age groups admitted in the medical wards of ABSUTH as shown inTable 5 is statistically significant (X2 = 111.91, p < 0.05)

Table 5 Outcome of medical admissions stratified by age groups in ABSUTH
Discharged home alive Died DAMA Referred to other centres/specialties Total
Age (years): <20 152 19 10 12 193
20-39 1055 341 83 105 1584
40-59 1503 506 101 87 2197
60 and above 1859 625 95 34 2613
Total 4569 1491 289 238 6587

Table 6 Outcome of treatment of the major diseases that caused medical admissions
HIV/AIDS DM complications stroke HF CKD HTN malaria
Home 390 915 437 646 220 302 256
Dead 279(4.24%) 249(3.78%) 352(5.34%) 106 111(1.69%) 6 7
DAMA 55 46 36 20 17 8 10
Referred 128 10 6 5 24 0 0
Total 852 1220 831 777 372 316 273

DISCUSSION

The finding in this report that diabetes mellitus related complications, HIV/AIDS, stroke, heart failures, CKD, systemic hypertension, chronic liver diseases and acute malaria were the major diseases responsible for medical admissions in ABSUTH within the study period is comparable to what was found in many Nigerian studies 19, 16, 15 and in Assir region of Saudi Arabia 25 . That NCDs contributed 73% of the medical admissions in this study is similar to findings in Ido Ekiti 15 . Abakiliki 16 and Enugu 19 ; and, this is in keeping with the current trend of increasing burden of non-communicable diseases in Africa. The explanation for this finding could be as a result of the westernized diets, sedentary lifestyles, resultant obesity and rapid urbanization taking place in sub-Saharan African countries including Nigeria. Our findings differ from those reported in Asaba 20 and the rural community of Okada 17 where infectious and parasitic diseases were predominant causes of hospitalization in the medical wards.

In the index study, the elderly participants (60 years and above) were in majority among the age groups admitted in the medical wards just as was found in the Ido Ekiti 15 study. The reason for this is, probably, because the elderly are prone to decreased body immunity with increased disease susceptibility and degenerative diseases. In addition, advancing age is an established risk factor for NCDs which, in this study, were topmost in the profile of diseases that caused hospitalizations. It could, also, be because the developing world is experiencing an ageing population with increasing burden of chronic diseases 29 . Again, this may be in keeping with the WHO projection that the total geriatric population 29 will double from 605 million in 2002 to 1.2 billion in 2025 while their population in sub Saharan Africa will double between 2000 and 2030. This finding is a contrast to the situation in Okada 17 community of Igbinediom University Teaching hospital, Abakiliki 16 and 20 Asaba where infectious and parasitic diseases (communicable diseases) were the major causes of hospitalization. The middle aged (40 – 59 years) came second as the age group most commonly admitted in the medical wards in this report just as was found in the Ido Ekiti 15 study. The implication of this is the loss of man-hours and the negative economic consequences.

More females than males were hospitalized over the study period. Similar finding was reported in Uganda 23 but contradicts those of some other researchers from within and outside Nigeria 30, 22, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15 . This could be because the present study spanned over 10 years with more participants than the other studies which were for a period of 2-3 years with fewer study

population. It could, also, be due to a better health seeking behavior among females 31 as reported by Omemu et al despite that it has been documented that males are at more risks than females for DM, strokes, CKD and other NCDs 32 . The teenagers (under-20 age group) had the least number of medical admissions in this study probably because NCDs which were predominant causes of hospitalization are uncommon in this age group.

The mortality rate of 22.6% in this report is higher than what was reported in some previous Nigerian studies 19, 18, 17, 16, 15 and Assir region of Saudi Arabia 25 but lower than the rate reported in Kano 21 . Reason for these differences in mortality in the published studies is not clear. In the index study, the contribution of stroke, heart failures, DM related complications and CKD to the medical wards mortality within the study period is comparable to the findings in related studies in Nigeria 22, 20, 16, 15 ). Stroke was the predominant cause of death probably because of the high prevalence of cerebrovascular risk factors (systemic arterial hypertension and DM) and increasing age of the study population. Similar to some other studies 20, 15 , this study showed that HIV/AIDS was a leading cause of death among the communicable diseases. This is not surprising since, unlike other CDs, HIV/AIDS is associated with many life-threatening opportunistic infections such as tuberculosis and viral infections. Infectious and parasitic diseases were not the leading cause of medical admissions or the commonest cause of death in this study unlike the situation in the Okada 17 study. A possible explanation for this could be increased personal hygiene and environmental sanitation due to the monthly cleaning exercise embarked upon by the states in the South East region of Nigeria for over a decade now.

Admission outcome data in this study are comparable to findings in the Kano study 21 . The implication of these findings is the need to improve public health programs aimed at preventing and controlling NCDs such as increase in health awareness and education programs. With this in place, cultural and superstitious beliefs that resulted to late presentations to hospitals and increased rate of DAMA will be minimized. It is important to note that systemic arterial hypertension and acute malaria were common causes of medical admission in this study but death as a result of either of them was scanty. Again, no case of snake bite was managed in the medical wards within the study period despite referral of patients from neighboring agrarian communities. Reasons for this are not clear but it could be that the superstitious tendency of the populace informed their decision not to bring snake bites patients to be treated in ABSUTH or that such patients with snake bites were treated and discharged home from or died at the Emergency unit of ABSUTH.

In this study, the mean duration of hospital stay was comparable to other Nigerian studies 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15 It is important to note that the longest duration of hospital stay was recorded among patients managed for diabetic foot/hand ulcers and gangrene and patients that had stroke while short duration of hospitalization (24 hours) was common in those that died. The latter could be because of late presentation to the hospitals as a result of illiteracy, poverty and superstitions.

Finally, findings from the index study could serve as a clinical audit of the medical wards of ABSUTH, Aba. Our findings could serve as a useful guide to the hospital management and other relevant stakeholders in the health sector in allocation of healthcare resources and other strategies to improve healthcare in the state. It will, also, serve as an important monitoring and evaluation tool for the Department of Internal Medicine, ABSUTH, Aba.

CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATION

This study has shown that the elderly aged persons and females were predominantly admitted in the medical wards of ABSUTH, Aba within the period under review. Again, diseases responsible for most admissions in the medical wards were diabetes mellitus related complications, HIV/AIDS, stroke, heart failures, chronic kidney diseases, systemic arterial hypertension, chronic liver diseases and acute malaria. While NCDs constituted a majority of the medical admissions in ABSUTH, Aba, stroke, HIV/AIDS and DM related complications were the major causes of death in the medical wards..It is, hereby, recommended that effective health education programmes be put in place to check the increasing prevalence and impact of these diseases.

CONFLICTS OF INTEREST – Nil

References

  1. Bin Abdulhak. Pattern, duration of stay and Outcomes of medical admissions: a report from teaching Community hospital in Assir region, Saudi Arabia Mushabab A, Al-Ghamdi Aref A. J. Community Hosp Intern. Med. Perspect.2018;8(2):53-56.
  2. Global and regional burden of disease and risk factors, 2001: systematic analysis of population health data Lopez Alan D, Mathers Colin D, Ezzati Majid, Jamison Dean T, Murray Christopher JL. The Lancet.2006;367(9524):1747-1757.
  3. Awareness of high blood pressure status, treatment and control in a rural community in Edo state Omemu V O, Okogie O H, Omemu Ceo. Nig J Clinical Pract.2007;10:208-212.
  4. Some emerging issues in medical admission pattern in the tropics Akintunde AA, Okunola OO, Akinwusi PO. Nigerian Journal of Clinical Practice.2012;15(1):51-51.
  5. Gender and global health: evidence, policy, and inconvenient truths Hawkes Sarah, Buse Kent. The Lancet.2013;381(9879):1783-1787.
  6. Medical causes of admissions to hospital among adults in Africa: a systematic review Etyang Anthony O., Gerard Scott John Anthony. Global Health Action.2013;6(1):19090-19090.
  7. The pattern of admissions into the medical wards of the University of Nigeria Teaching hospital, Enugu Ike S O. Niger J Clin Pract.2008;11(3):185-192.
  8. Pattern and outcome of medical admissions in a Nigerian rural teaching hospital Osarenkhoe J, Omoruyi L, Imarhiagbe L, Adebayo O, Freeman O. Ann Trop Med Public Health.2009;7:171-177.
  9. Abu Hosan Sarkar. Pattern and Outcome of Patients Attending a Tertiary Care Hospital Bishnu Ram Das Anuradha, Hazarika Medhi Netri, Das Gitali, Kakoti Gunjan, Nath Int. J. Curr. Res. Aca. Rev.2016;4(4):21-28.
  10. Counting the dead and what they died from: an assessment of the global status of cause of death data Mathers C D, Fat D M, Inoue M, Rao C, Lopez A D. Bull World Health Organ.2005;83:171-177.
  11. Pattern of medical admissions at the Federal Medical Centre, Asaba: A two year review Odenigbo C U, Oguejiofor O C. Niger J Clin Pract.2009;12:395-402.
  12. Moscow: WHO World Health Organisation. New WHO report: Death from noncommunicable diseases on the rise, developing world hit hardest.2011.
  13. Global status report on non-communicable diseases: Geneva: World Health Organization 2010.
  14. Pattern of Diseases among Medical Admissions in Port Harcourt, Nigeria. Agomuoh D I, Unachukwu C N. Nigerian Medical Practitioner.2008;51:45-50.
  15. Pattern and outcome of admissions in the medical wards of a tertiary health center in a rural community of Ekiti state, Nigeria Ogunmola OlarindeJ, Oladosu OlatunjiY. Annals of African Medicine.2014;13(4):195-195.
  16. Trends of admissions and case fatality rates among medical in-patients at a tertiary hospital in Uganda; A four-year retrospective study Kalyesubula Robert, Mutyaba Innocent, Rabin Tracy, Andia-Biraro Irene, Alupo Patricia, Kimuli Ivan, Nabirye Stella, Kagimu Magid, Mayanja-Kizza Harriet, Rastegar Asghar, Kamya Moses R.. PLOS ONE.2019;14(5):e0216060-e0216060.
  17. Population aging and implication, for epidemic cardiovascular disease in sub-Saharan Africa Smith S M, Mensah G A. Ethn Dis.2003;13:577-80.
  18. Mortality patterns in the Medical Wards of Murtala Muhammad Specialist Hospital, Kano, Nigeria Hadiza Saidu. Nigerian Journal of Basic and Clinical Sciences.2018;15(1):73-73.
  19. The Epidemiologic Transition Theory. A Preliminary Update Omran A. R.. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics.1983;29(6):305-316.
  20. Reasons and outcomes of admissions to the medical wards of Jimma University Specialized Hospital, southwest Ethiopia Elias A, Mirkuzie W. Ethiop J Health Sci.2010;20(2):113-120.
  21. Potential Uses and Limitations of Hospital Data in Epidemiologic Research Masi Alfonse T.. American Journal of Public Health and the Nations Health.1965;55(5):658-667.
  22. World Bank; World development report 1993: investing in health Washington, DC .
  23. Disease burden in sub-Saharan Africa: what should we conclude in the absence of data? Cooper Richard S, Osotimehin Babatunde, Kaufman Jay S, Forrester Terrence. The Lancet.1998;351(9097):208-210.
  24. The Epidemiologic Transition: A Theory of the Epidemiology of Population Change OMRAN ABDEL R.. Milbank Quarterly.2005;83(4):731-757.
  25. Outlook for survivors of childhood in sub Saharan Africa: adult mortality in Tanzania. Adult morbidity and mortality project Kitange H M, Machibya H, Black J, Mtasiwa D M, Masuki G, Whiting D. BMJ.1996;312:216-220.
  26. Disease and mortality in sub Saharan Africa Jamison D T, Feachem R G, Malegapuru W M, Bos E R, Baingana F K. World Bank; 2006.
  27. Utilization of Beds in a tertiary care hospital Kiran Ravi, Vijaya K. JAHA.2003;15(2).
  28. International statistical classification of diseases and health-related problems. Geneva: World Health Organisation 2004.
  29. Global and Regional Burden of Infective Endocarditis, 1990–2010: A Systematic Review of the Literature Bin Abdulhak Aref A., Baddour Larry M., Erwin Patricia J., Hoen Bruno, Chu Vivian H., Mensah George A., Tleyjeh Imad M.. Global Heart.2014;9(1):131-131.
  30. Disease Control Priorities in Developing Countries Pearson T A, Jamison D T, Tergo-Gauderies J, Jamison DT, Mosley WH. New York. NY: Oxford University Press; 1993.
  31. Pattern and outcome of medical admissions at the Ogun State University Teaching Hospital, Sagamu- a three year review Ogun S A, Adelowo O O, Familoni O B, Jaiyesimi A E, Fakoya E A. West Afr J Med.2000;19(4):304-308.